NSFW tag because I can’t really talk about this without mentioning how it’s often weaponized against furries/other kink communities - one example in particular that comes to mind is how radfems will claim that anyone who is a BDSM sub needs therapy. It’s a way to dress up condemnation of others in virtuous-sounding language - “I’m just concerned about their mental health!” - and carries a lot of ugly implications:
- Scientism: A lot of people making these claims take up the language of psychology without looking at what actual psychologists have to say. I’ve seen many behaviors/kinks (again: radfems and BDSM) get labeled as “insane” by people who have a layperson’s understanding of psychology at best and who completely contradict modern psychology at worst. All they really do is give a false sense of authority to their own prejudices.
- Ableism: These accusations often get leveled against neurodiverse people by a society that, while having seen some improvements, largely sees autism and other manifestations of neurodiversity as something “wrong” that needs to be forcibly corrected.
- Infantilization: Implicit in accusing someone of being insane/unhealthy is the idea that they are not a full adult person - that is, they can’t be trusted to make their own decisions and need to be controlled by someone more “competent.” This has historically been used against a wide variety of marginalized groups to justify depriving them of their rights and self-determination.
- Violent Implications: Modern society’s treatment of those it deemed “insane” has historically been horrific, locking them up and imposing upon them damaging and torturous “cures” such as lobotomization, conversion therapy, ABA, and basically anything done by the troubled teen industry. Even in institutions that are above-board and operating on the latest and best knowledge of psychology, neglect and abuse of patients is distressingly common. Implicit in the accusation that someone is “mentally unwell” is, at best, to say that it’s justified to force them into a situation where they are at a high level of risk for abuse and neglect.
Hopefully this goes without saying, but obviously this does not apply to kinks/paraphilias/other non-normative behaviors that actually, provably harm others. If someone’s actually hurting people (or is a credible danger of doing so), they need to be stopped. Pathologizing a behavior carries its own inherent risk of hurting innocent people, though, and for that reason it demands a high standard of proof.
Everyone thinking they’re a therapist and are doing therapy to randoms online that they don’t know and its consequences. It’s an amazing way to patronize people while seeming innocent.
It unfortunately is not just an online thing, or a celebrity thing anymore. It’s everywhere now. Reminds me of this classic article:
“They don’t talk about their feelings. They talk about talking about their feelings"
Good article. And I hate the overuse of the term ‘self care’ so fucking much. It’s a hedonistic indulgence most of the time being described as such and being treated as something necessary. Treat it as the indulgence it is instead of lying to yourself and pretending it’s some sort if physiological necessity or obligation, you’ll have more fun that way. Otherwise you’re just making enjoying something another form of productivity. Also I don’t get the same cheap thrill from consumerism that this mentality requires. I don’t go shopping looking for things I might like cause they aren’t out there. My clothes are thrifted and I know how to screen print so I make my own graphics, I pirate my games and movies, I’ll.raid thrift stores for physical media of random weird shit and enjoy that, but that’s like a $20 thrill at the most. I’m a cook and vegan so I don’t really eat out. Aside from weed, smokes and booze which are just kinda normal day stuff, there isn’t really anything for me to spend money on and also I don’t have extra money. Even when I do I use it to take time off work.ost of the shit I like is really cheap.
Which is incredibly frustrating because any therapist worth their salt will tell you, they can’t diagnose a patient without personally meeting with that patient. There’s both medical and ethical reasons for this.
Yes. People should not be diagnosing people. Just be normal judgemental, you aren’t a better and more nuanced person for trying to think of why a cashier was rude to you and decide they have BPD or something, they may just be having a bad day or you are more likely just a shitty customer, you’re actually worse. Turning any uncomfortable interaction as an excuse to pathologize the other person is nothing more than a very self gratifying way of avoiding any self reflection. Now instead of thinking maybe it sucks to be a cashier and you could have been more pleasant the cashier has bpd and you’re just soooo smart for noticing.
I don’t want to add much, but I completely agree.
Kinks are still deeply pathologized in a very shameful way. Apart from my partners, only my closest friends know all of the nasty shit I like. And I live in total fear I’ll run into a partner that will expose what a kinky bastard I am to everyone that thinks I’m just a very normie, vanilla guy. It’s so dumb some of have to hide being into this shit.
When people are quick to pathologize any differences they encounter, I’m pretty quick to aggressively ridicule them at this point in my life. It just suggests to me that they’re a total fucking baby who doesn’t have adequate exposure to other people or something like that.
Removed by mod
I guarantee you that Kalahari bushmen don’t have time or inclination to be furries or get tied up.
I guarantee you they do
It was only missionary until we left the caves, right?
I’d bet anything that doggy was our common ancestor’s first sex position.
Absolutely guarantee this. Missionary requires a very very upright posture. Also it’s how most animals fuck, dogs just get the credit cause probably it’s the animal people saw fuck the most and people are gross.
I’ll judge you for being racist, ableist and a bigot regarding any form of sexual expression that isn’t missionary