Saw this in hexbear memes yesterday. To me it reads as a satire of the holier than thou attitudes I see around here. But it also had no downvotes and nobody was challenging it, so I wonder if it reads differently to you, and how if so.

I tried asking the OP but I was told not to expect discussion in the memes community

  • TheDoctor [they/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
    36·
    16 days ago

    I thought the point of this was that the meme normally has the other track(s) connected to the middle track, so the fact that they’re disconnected means the lever doesn’t do anything and the system is designed to give a false sense of choice to cover up its murderous intent.

    • RedWizard [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
      26·
      16 days ago

      That’s how I read it. The tracks have to be connected.

      If you are standing with the leaver, the trolley can’t change tracks, no matter how much you pull it.

      If you’re standing at the leaverless track, you don’t even have the illusion of control over the situation.

      The only moral choice in this image is to get on the moving trolley and try to stop it yourself.

      Which is always an option in each one of these trolley images.

      Ultimately, the “Trolley Problem” is stupid as a rhetorical device because life isn’t binary.

    • Lojcs@lemm.eeOPEnglish
      10·
      16 days ago

      And still, choosing an empty track doesn’t do anything neither other than letting the person on the bottom feel better about themselves. If the guy on the top is a play on the liberal ‘choose the lesser evil’ sentiment, what is the bottom guy about?

      • TheDoctor [they/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
        20·
        16 days ago

        If all 3 tracks are an option, the bottom track not doing anything is the point because the alternative is murder. But I’m saying that in this meme there really is no option other than the middle track because the other 2 aren’t attached.