Found this article in the longreads community arguing why “politically correct” terms shouldn’t be used. You guys have any thoughts?
Found this article in the longreads community arguing why “politically correct” terms shouldn’t be used. You guys have any thoughts?
I think that the text has some merit, but it misses the full picture, and the conclusion is crap.
Sure, what matters is what you say, on a discursive level; not the specific words that you use to say it. And meaning is not hard-coded into the words, it depends on a thousand things, it changes over time, yadda yadda.
So far, so good. However meaning doesn’t depend on “intent”, as the intent only exists inside the head of the speaker; meaning is socially negotiated between the speaker and hearers. And some words become associated with prejudice in a way that, even if the speaker tries to cancel it out, they still sound “unfortunate”.
I also think that the author is building a big strawman on what “politically correct language” is supposed to be. It is not just about the individual words.
At the end of the day it’s about manners and putting forth a reasonable effort to make others feel welcome and comfortable.
Yup, pretty much.