I’m on my first read through of the Witcher. I’ve stalled on the tower of swallows though.
It’s almost cyberpunkesque in how much the world hates it’s inhabitants. Which was interesting when it followed cyberpunk themes of “forget thriving, the goal is to survive this world”.
But, the players are in bigger arenas now, so the world is just a shit place to be. I find myself struggling to care about the politics, or follow who’s who. The early books geralt is so apathetic it didn’t matter which kingdom or who’s the prevailing lord. So I ,like geralt, just didn’t care. Now I’m supposed to, good development for geralt. I just don’t want to suddenly learn the names of 40 kingdoms, their kings, recent history etc…
The prevailing magic seems to be the vow, you’re fucked in a fucked world if you break one. Cool concept, I like it, but it does get watered down because the world wants to grind you down anyway. Breaking a vow is just another excuse for the universe to hurt you. I’ll probably push through this and decide if I want to keep going.
The early books the gang is quite small easy to follow and I enjoyed them enough to continue.
But later the cast balloons quite heavily. I did play the games and thought that would be enough, but I’m god awful names at the best of times. So scene with sorceress #15 and Lord #16 in kingdom #4 is usually me thinking “who’s any of that again?”
Partly, it’s because I’m reading by audio in situations where I can’t easily pause and consider. Partly, because the author just spent 3 books telling me these are Eldrich forces for geralt to avoid as best as possible, so why would I try understand them. Partly, because the stories are less interesting to me now as previously mentioned.